What is confirmed
- Little Chef (50 G) — discover and successfully brew a secret recipe.
- Toil and Trouble (10 G) — spoil a brew three times in a row.
- Brewing uses a recipe book at the witch’s cottage.
How to experiment without wasting a session
- Keep a buffer of common ingredients. Do not dump every rare ingredient into a random brew.
- Brew one unknown combination at a time. Note what changed in the recipe book or UI.
- Watch for a “new recipe” flag. The achievement requires discovering the recipe, not just brewing a random mix.
- Do not fear spoiling. Toil and Trouble is only 10 G and explicitly rewards three failures in a row; it is not a punishment system.
What not to trust
Pre-release “secret recipe” lists are guesswork. The official pages do not name the recipe or its ingredients. Wait for the launch build or a verified screenshot.